I am thinking 5 nights - arrive 4/24, depart 4/29. All these options are for 2 bedroom condos with kitchen. and have indicated availability, unless noted that they have not yet responded to my inquiry.

Name of Resort
Website
Accomodations
Comments
Grassy Key Beach Motel & Resort
www.thekeysresort.com
"Dolphin" $219
50" TV plus TV in master BR
2 balconies overlook pool or beach
They only have 10 units
Built in 2000
I think this one is my favorite so far
Continental Inn
www.marathonresort.com
$160 for 4 people
Nice slideshow tour on website
Yellow Tail Inn
www.yellowtailinn.com
starts at $239
I like unit 104 - ocean front
Pool is really small!, and so is beach
Gulf View Resort
www.gulfviewwaterfrontresort.com
2 options:
King bedroom + Queen bedroom = $179
Queen br & Queen br = $149

complimentary rentals of:
kayaks, canoes, paddle boats
There are only 11 units
It kind of looks "no frills"

Crystal Bay Resort
www.crystalbayresort.com
NO RESPONSE YET
online rates appear to start at $220 for what we need
Free mini golf
slideshow on website, but I'm not that impressed
Sea Shell Beach Resort
www.seashellbeachresort.com
NO RESPONSE YET
no rates on website
There are only 10 units
website doesn't show much